Mastelo lands beside the waterline
Tsikali places family-run taverna tables directly on Vathi beach, with children stepping from lunch onto the sand. Clay-pot mastelo, cod, pork souvlaki, cheese pies and baked sweets keep the cooking Sifnian even as the bay fills with yachts.
Access requires the Vathi road and parking tightens near the waterfront, so arrive before 13:30 or use the bus. Ask which clay-pot dishes remain, compare portion size before ordering several mains and inspect fish prices by weight; recent diners praise fast service but find some signature portions costly.
What visitors say
Tripadvisor lists about 545 reviews and a Travelers' Choice award; June 2026 diners praise cod, souvlaki and prompt service, while repeated friction concerns price relative to mastelo portion size.
Good to know
Vathi beachfront, Clay pot Sifnian dishes, Family run taverna, and Travelers' Choice